Is That Advent Calendar Worth It? What the SKIMS Flop Teaches Us

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, Living Well for Seniors may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Advent calendars have come a long way from the cardboard ones with a sliver of chocolate behind each door. Today they come from jewelers, beauty brands, wine makers, and fashion labels, and many cost well over $100. That makes the question of what’s actually inside a lot more important.

This month, SKIMS learned that lesson in public. Its $148 accessories calendar went viral for the wrong reasons when unboxing videos revealed hair ties, bobby pins, scrunchies, hair clips, and keychains behind its twelve doors. Shoppers compared the contents to what you’d find at the bottom of a purse, and the brand ended up offering refunds or store credit to buyers. The calendar is now sold out with a waitlist.

The takeaway isn’t that advent calendars are a bad buy. It’s that a little homework before you click “add to cart” goes a long way.

How to Tell If an Advent Calendar Is Worth the Price

Look for the spoiler list

Most brands, or the beauty and gift sites that cover them, publish a full contents list. If a calendar keeps its contents a complete secret, treat that as a reason to wait for reviews rather than buy blind.

Do your own math on the “value”

A box that says “$250 value” usually adds up the retail price of small sample sizes, which cost more per ounce than full-size products. Divide the price by the number of doors to see what you’re paying per item, then ask whether you’d pay that for each one on its own.

Count the doors

Twelve-day calendars are becoming more common, and they often hold larger or full-size items. Twenty-four-day calendars give you more daily surprises but usually smaller ones. Neither is better; just know which you’re getting.

Think about who will open it

Skincare and fragrance are personal, so a beauty calendar works best for someone who already loves that brand. Jewelry and food calendars tend to be safer bets for gifting.

Check the return policy

Many limited-edition holiday sets are final sale or excluded from promotions. Read the fine print before you buy, especially for higher-priced calendars.

Advent Calendars Worth Opening This Year

For the Jewelry Lover

Kendra Scott

Kendra Scott 2026 12 Days of Joy Gold Bestsellers Box

The Kendra Scott 2026 12 Days of Joy Gold Bestsellers Box is the opposite of the SKIMS problem: twelve full-size pieces of the brand’s bestselling necklaces, earrings, and bracelets in 14k gold over brass. It’s priced at $398 for an $840 value, which works out to roughly $33 a piece. It’s also easy to keep a few favorites and gift the rest.

Pure Vida

Pura Vida 24 Day Advent Calendar

For a lighter, more casual option, the Pura Vida 24 Day Advent Calendar offers a full countdown of the brand’s colorful jewelry. It’s a fun choice to share with a granddaughter, with pieces to trade back and forth.

For the Bath and Body Lover

L’Occitane

L'Occitane Advent Calendar Set Limited Edition

The L’Occitane Advent Calendar Set at Nordstrom is a limited edition with a stated $257 value. It’s a good fit for anyone who already loves the brand’s shea hand cream and Provence-inspired body care.

The Body Shop

The Body Shop Ultimate Advent Calendar

The Body Shop’s Ultimate Advent Calendar is packed with bath and body favorites, the kind of everyday treats that actually get used up rather than tucked in a drawer.

Uncommon Goods 24 Day Luxe

Uncommon Goods 24 Day Luxe Body Care Advent Calendar

For something a little different from the big beauty brands, the 24 Day Luxe Body Care Advent Calendar from Uncommon Goods offers a daily dose of pampering in a pretty keepsake box.

Victoria’s Secret

Victoria's Secret 12 Days of Bombshell Advent Calendar

Fragrance fans will want to look at the Victoria’s Secret 12 Days of Bombshell Advent Calendar, which features holiday exclusives and the new Bombshell Desire scent.

Just for Fun

2026 Wine Advent Calendar

2026 Wine Advent Calendar

A 2026 Wine Advent Calendar turns the countdown into a nightly tasting, and it’s a smart way to discover new varieties without committing to full bottles.

Williams-Sonoma

Williams-Sonoma Grinch Advent

If the grandchildren will be around in December, The Grinch Advent Calendar from Williams-Sonoma is a festive pick the whole family can enjoy opening together.

Journey To Bethlehem

Advent calendar from Wayfair

And for a calendar you can bring out year after year, this reusable advent calendar from Wayfair lets you fill the doors yourself, with treats, notes, or small gifts chosen for the people you love.

The Bottom Line

A good advent calendar should feel like a small gift every day, not a box of odds and ends. Read the contents list, do the per-door math, and choose one that fits the person opening it. That’s the best way to make sure December’s surprises are happy ones.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *